Trader Joe's British Style Crumpets is the pillowy, pockmarked round of toasted breakfast bread that most American shoppers walk right past without realizing what they're missing - six dense, spongy crumpets in a clear pouch with a little Big Ben on the label. They sit on the bread shelf near the Dutch Griddle Cakes and the Gluten Free English Muffins, and they're the kind of unassuming carb that turns into something special once you toast it and load it with butter, jam, or honey.
Quick Take: A spongy, butter-loving British breakfast bread with holes engineered to catch melted everything - way better than an English muffin. Verdict: Buy. Scores: Taste ⅘ · Value ⅘ · Convenience 5/5 · Cult Score ⅗.
First impression
I'd never bought crumpets before this. The pouch looked weird (translucent, almost industrial), the crumpets looked vaguely like flat English muffins with chickenpox, and I had no real idea what to do with them. The toaster was the move.
Three minutes later, the tops were golden, the bottoms were crisp, and the bubbly tops had become the best butter delivery vehicle I've ever seen - those holes don't just catch butter, they demand it. The texture inside is dense and spongy in a really specific way that's not quite bread, not quite pancake. Once you've had one done right, you get why the Brits keep them in business.
Price & value
The 11 oz / 312g pack of 6 crumpets runs about $2.99 at most TJ's. That's roughly 50 cents per crumpet - same neighborhood as English muffins, but with a much more interesting personality. Compare that to specialty bakery crumpets at Whole Foods, which can hit $6-7 for a 4-pack of the artisan version.
For a TJ shopper looking to vary the morning carb routine, this is one of the cheapest swaps you can make. They keep at room temp for a week and freeze well if you want to stash a pack.
Nutrition snapshot
Nutrition snapshot (per crumpet): 100 cal · 0g fat · 22g carbs · 0g sugar · 3g protein · 290mg sodium. Notable: zero fat, zero added sugar, and a clean ingredient list - water, enriched wheat flour, malted barley flour, yeast. Just be aware of the sodium if you're eating two.
Taste, quality, or performance
The texture is the whole story. You have to toast them - eating one fresh from the bag is a sad, doughy experience. Pop it in the toaster for 2-3 minutes (or under the broiler for 1-2) and the top crisps into a golden, slightly crunchy lid while the inside stays soft and spongy. The bottom gets a nice crust. The flavor on its own is mild - a faint yeasty tang, barely sweet, slightly malty from the barley flour - which is exactly the point. The crumpet is a vehicle, not the destination.
What goes on top matters. Butter is mandatory (it pools in the holes and seeps down into the sponge - there's no improving on this). After that, the variations get fun: honey and a sprinkle of flaky salt for a fancy breakfast; cream cheese and smoked salmon for a savory move; a fried egg on top for a budget brunch sandwich; melted cheddar for the laziest open-faced grilled cheese of all time. Berry jam is the classic - bonus points for a spoonful of homemade fruit sauce.
A pro tip: if you have a few crumpets left and they've gone slightly stale, toast them twice. First pass at medium, second pass at a higher setting. They come out even crisper than fresh.
What other shoppers are saying
These get a quiet but loyal following on the TJ shopper communities - the most common comment is "why don't Americans eat these all the time?" Shoppers who grew up in the UK or who travel there often call out that these are surprisingly close to the supermarket crumpets back home, which is high praise from a notoriously picky audience.
The most common complaint: people who bite into one straight from the bag (without toasting) and assume they're bad. Don't skip the toaster. A few shoppers note that the holes can vary pack-to-pack - some crumpets have huge butter-catching pockets, others are more closed-up.
Who it's for & best uses
This is for anyone bored of English muffins, breakfast adventurers who want to upgrade their toast situation, people who host a brunch and want to put something interesting on the table, and parents looking for a new vehicle for jam-loving kids. Three uses worth trying: classic butter and honey with morning tea; topped with cream cheese and a spoonful of homemade blueberry sauce for a quick fancy breakfast; or as the base for a quick savory breakfast - fried egg, melted cheese, hot sauce. Dietary notes: contains wheat; vegan-friendly if you stick to non-dairy toppings.
Similar items
- Trader Joe's Gluten Free English Muffins - the GF-friendly cousin for the same "carb base for breakfast toppings" use case.
- Trader Joe's Dutch Griddle Cakes - the closest TJ relative, described literally as "a cross between a pancake and a crumpet."
- Trader Joe's Glazed Sweet Lemon Scones - the sweeter British-leaning breakfast move if you want to lean into the tea-time vibe.
- 3-Ingredient Blueberry Sauce - make this once on a Sunday and you've got crumpet toppings for the whole week.
- The Best Banana Grits Recipe - totally different format, same "cozy breakfast that feels nicer than the effort it takes" energy.
The scores
- Taste - ⅘. Mild on its own, brilliant as a butter-and-jam vehicle. The texture is genuinely special.
- Value - ⅘. $2.99 for 6 crumpets is solid; cheaper than specialty bakery alternatives.
- Convenience - 5/5. Toaster, 3 minutes, done. Shelf-stable for a week.
- Cult Score - ⅗. Beloved by the people who know about them, mostly ignored by everyone else.
Verdict
Buy. This is one of those underrated TJ items that turns a normal breakfast into something a little nicer for almost no extra effort. Repeat-Buy if you're a butter-and-jam person - once you've experienced what those pockmarked tops do to melted butter, regular toast feels a little sad. The main thing to remember: always toast them. Always.
Where to find it: Trader Joe's British Style Crumpets, 11 oz at Trader Joe's - note that this product isn't currently listed on Trader Joe's online catalog, but it's a regular in-store item. Pack size: 11 oz / 312g (6 crumpets). Price: ~$2.99 at most stores. Storage: shelf-stable; keeps about a week at room temp or freezes well. Aisle: bread section near the English muffins and bagels.
Leave a Reply