Trader Joe's Pumpkin Joe-Joe's are a seasonal twist on the classic sandwich cookie, bringing pumpkin spice into the beloved Joe-Joe format. Every fall, these bright orange cookies pop up on shelves, and they're one of those products that Trader Joe's fans either grab immediately or risk missing out on until next year.
What's in the box
Each box contains a row of sandwich cookies: crisp pumpkin-colored wafers with a creamy pumpkin spice filling in between. The cookies get their flavor from pumpkin powder and spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove. The filling is sweet and creamy, with a pumpkin pie vibe. Unlike some pumpkin spice items that lean on vague "flavoring," these actually use pumpkin as part of the ingredient list.
Taste and texture
The first bite is crunchy and sweet-the cookie itself has a bit of that Oreo-style snap but with a softer pumpkin note. The filling is smooth, spiced, and a little heavy on the sweetness, but that's part of what makes these cookies a treat. If you love pumpkin pie, you'll likely enjoy how the spices come through. For me, the balance leans more toward sugar than spice, but dipping them in coffee or tea helps mellow that sweetness.
How I like to enjoy them
I've tried these straight from the box, but I think they really shine when dunked in a hot drink-coffee, chai, or even Trader Joe's Spiced Cider. The warmth makes the filling softer and amplifies the pumpkin pie flavor. Another fun way is crumbling them on top of vanilla ice cream, or even Trader Joe's Pumpkin Ice Cream if you want to go all in on fall flavors.
Best pairing I've tried
The best way I enjoyed them? With a glass of cold milk and one or two cookies. Simple, classic, and it let me appreciate the spiced filling without it feeling too heavy. They also worked surprisingly well with Trader Joe's Pumpkin Brioche Twist, where I crumbled a cookie into yogurt alongside a slice of toasted brioche-it was like a deconstructed fall dessert.
Portion size & value
A box is reasonably priced and gives you enough cookies to share, though I admit they disappear fast in my house. They're not an everyday cookie, but as a seasonal splurge, the value feels right. The size is similar to Oreos-portable, easy to pack in lunches, or to set out on a fall snack tray.
Similar products
If you're eyeing these, you might also like:
- Trader Joe's Maple Leaf Cookies - another fall cookie with a sweet, spiced filling.
- Trader Joe's Pumpkin Brioche Twist - softer, bread-based treat that pairs well with sweet spreads or crumbled cookies.
- Trader Joe's Minty Flavored Cocoa Truffles - a different holiday sweet, but another seasonal treat worth trying if you're exploring TJ's seasonal aisle.
- Trader Joe's Pumpkin Ice Cream - creamy pumpkin goodness that pairs beautifully with a couple of Joe-Joe's crumbled on top.
Would I buy again?
Yes-once a season. They're fun, festive, and definitely scratch that pumpkin spice itch, but they're a little too sweet for me to keep around all fall.
Final thoughts
Trader Joe's Pumpkin Joe-Joe's are a festive cookie that delivers on the pumpkin spice promise in a snackable, shareable format. They're not the most balanced cookie flavor-wise, but they're worth picking up if you want a fall dessert that feels playful and cozy. I'd rate them 4 out of 5 stars.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐☆☆
Leave a Reply